Showing posts with label collapse of Lehman Brothers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label collapse of Lehman Brothers. Show all posts

Saturday, January 9, 2016

The Big Fraud behind "The Big Short"

Did you or someone you know lose a job, business, home or money in their retirement accounts during the Great Recession that began in 2007?  If so, you know that the losses continued to affect people around the world for the next decade, or longer.

Millions of Baby Boomers lost so much money in their IRAs and 401(k)s that they had to postpone their retirement ... if they were able to retire at all.

If you want to understand the fraud behind the Great Recession, and the actions that need to be taken in order to prevent it from happening again, either read the book or watch the movie, "The Big Short."  The movie, in particular, explains in terms that nearly anyone can understand how it all started. 

Background Information About The Big Fraud Behind "The Big Short"


After the Great Depression in the 1930's, Congress passed the Glass-Steagall Act.  The purpose of this act was to prevent another collapse in the banking system, such as the one that occurred during the Depression.

While there were many aspects to Glass-Steagall beyond what is mentioned here, an important one was that stock brokerage firms and banks were required to be completely separate.  Banks needed to be conservative and stodgy, sticking with low-risk investments.  Brokerage firms had more restrictive rules to follow, such as limiting the amount of stock that could be purchased on margin, but they could take more risks than banks.

Beginning around 2002, the Glass-Steagall Act was dismantled.  Banks and brokerage firms were allowed to merge and buy each other, creating large banking institutions like Lehman Brothers that were considered "too big to fail."

Once banks and brokerage firms were connected and other financial rules were weakened, new types of investment products were created.  Banks began to package mortgages into bundles that their brokerage departments could sell like stocks.

Simultaneously, the conservative rules banks had previously followed before approving mortgage loans also began to be relaxed.  More "Ninja" loans, which stood for mortgages offered to people with No Income No Job, became available. 

At first these bundles of mortgages were good investments, since they were primarily made up of AAA mortgages.  However, these bundles of mortgages began to contain more and more of the BB or Ninja loans.  These loans had a high default rate.  When enough of the borrowers of those loans defaulted, the entire bundle of mortgages became worthless.

This is where the fraud came in.  The investors were not told that they were buying bundles of mortgages that contained a high percentage of Ninja loans.  Instead, they were told their investments were made up almost entirely of AAA loans. 

Sooner or later, these investments were bound to collapse ... but only a few people recognized that this was on the verge of happening.  Those who did see it coming shorted these investments ... hence, "The Big Short." However, when it happened, the losses brought down several of the big banks ... so many, in fact, that the world's economies almost certainly would have collapsed if the banks had not been rescued.

This created a ripple effect that brought down more than the big banks.  Billions of dollars were lost in the stock market.  Jobs were lost.  Defaults on mortgages accelerated. With higher unemployment and money lost in the stock market, people could not afford consumer goods.  The auto industry and related businesses began to collapse.  As these industries got in trouble, unemployment spiraled up, and the economies spiraled down.

Most of us know that it has taken close to a decade for the economy to recover ... and it is still very fragile.

Now that you understand the background, you will appreciate "The Big Short" even more, whether you watch the movie or read the book.  It is well worth the two hours, especially if you never want to see anything like this happen again!


See the trailer of "The Big Short" at:  https://twitter.com/thebigshort/status/668881794112946176

Photo courtesy of "The Big Short" on Twitter.

#TheBigShort #InvestmentFraud #GlassSteagall

Sunday, August 19, 2012

The Collapse of Lehman Brothers

On September 15, 2008, Lehman Brothers, the fourth largest investment bank in the United States, declared bankruptcy, causing confusion and chaos in international investment markets.  The effect of the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy was the financial disaster that we are living through right now and it continues to affect people around the world.  Essentially, the domino effect of the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy caused the worst financial disaster in 70 years.

Since the 2008 bankruptcy, there have been no prosecutions of the major executives, even though they intentionally manipulated their quarterly investment reports and financial records so that they did not reflect the real financial condition of the company.  Both the president of Lehman Brothers,  Richard S. Fuld, Jr., and their Ernst and Young auditors were considered culpable by financial examiners because Mr. Fuld oversaw the manipulation of the financial records and the auditors did not question the accounting practices of the company.  This is despite the fact that both the company president and the auditors received written objections from Lehman Brother's chief accountant who was concerned about the misleading financial picture that was being painted. 

According to the court appointed financial examiner, Anton Valukas, Lehman Brothers was using accounting gimmicks at the end of every quarter to make their finances look better that they really were.  The accounting tricks were called REPO 105, a system they devised in which they created repurchase agreements that would temporarily removed some obligations from the company's balance sheet so it looked as if they were better off than they really were.  In November 2007, their chief accountant refused to sign off on the accounting procedures being used by Lehman Brothers.  When he catalogued his concerns in writing, he ended up being fired.

When Lehman's case was settled, there were claims against it for approximately $370 billion.  Unfortunately, most of the investors had to settle for about 20 cents on the dollar.

Although Anton Valukas, the court appointed financial examiner, published his report about Lehman Brothers on March 11, 2010, according to a CBS "Sixty Minutes" television interview with him shown on August 19, 2012, no arrests have been made.  The SEC declined to discuss the case with the reporters at "Sixty Minutes."  According to a "Wall Street Journal" report in March, 2011, the SEC said that they were not pursuing a criminal case against anyone at Lehman Brothers or Ernst and Young at that time because they were not confident that US accounting laws had been broken.

Whether or not laws were broken, there is no question that executives at Lehman Brothers were intentionally lying to investors and to the American public.

You may also be interested in reading:

Politics and Lies
The Biggest Ponzi Scheme in U.S. History
Biggest Tax Fraud in Oregon

You are reading from the blog:  http://lies-and-liars.blogspot.com
Photo of Lehman Brothers headquarters courtesy of:  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lehman_Brothers